Councillor Davies said that he was not convinced that there was sufficient information to allow members to make an informed decision that the proposed tender was value for money and that it would generate the projected savings bearing in mind that some savings would be made from EVRs anyway. He emphasised that this was not just about cost savings and that the workforce should be given the opportunity to put in a reasonable bid for these services. There was clear evidence that the projected savings from the workforce were sustainable and the experience of users indicated that the services were well received and represented good value for money. He also referred to the risks associated Option 3.

He asked the Cabinet to reconsider its decision and allow the workforce to bid for this contract. He also reiterated the need for the Council to do all that it could to ensure the transfer of existing staff on the same terms and conditions and protect their current pension entitlement with the Merseyside Pension Fund.

Councillor Foulkes commented that the level of debate and questioning this evening had been very thorough.

He emphasised that this was not just about cost savings and that the workforce should be given the opportunity to put in a reasonable bid for these services. There was clear evidence that the projected savings from the workforce were sustainable and the experience of users indicated that the services were well received and represented good value for money. He also referred to the risks associated with a private contractor e.g. the Council’s experience with Continental Landscapes which had resulted in the service being taken back in-house.

He expressed his reservation regarding the consultation process and the need for an improved communication strategy which was acknowledged in the Gateway Review by the 4ps Organistion. He suggested that this was an appropriate time for the Council to demonstrate its commitment to consult with staff, trade unions, service users, and the general public, and include PACSPE in the brief for the Living in Wirral Task Force.

He urged the Cabinet to reconsider its decision and to capture the enthusiasm and dedication of the workforce by allowing them to bid for this contract.